Cutting closed out his Dragon career with an exceptional senior season, putting together marks of 18-4 in singles and 11-7 in doubles. He played almost exclusively from the No. 4 singles spot, going 15-1 and a perfect 5-0 in GMAC play. In doubles, he teamed up with Nikita Parfenov to go 9-7 from the No. 1 position, including 5-1 in conference action. Cutting earned First Team All-GMAC recognition and was also named the GMAC Player of the Week for the week of Feb. 25-Mar. 3.
Toby went 8-8 in singles in his junior campaign, going 5-3 at No. 4, 3-4 at No. 5, and 3-4 in GLIAC action. His most frequent doubles partner was Tom Arias, with the duo going 5-4 on the year at No. 3, including 5-2 in conference play.
Cutting went 14-8 in singles as a sophomore, including a 6-3 conference mark and records of 6-3 at No. 4 and 7-4 and No. 5. In doubles, he partnered with Luis Ludena to go 16-11 overall, playing all 23 of TU's No. 1 doubles pairings with a 15-8 record, including 6-3 in GLIAC play.
Cutting saw plenty of action during his freshman season, going 18-13 in singles play, splitting time between No. 3 (6-4) and No. 4 (6-7). He teamed up with Luis Ludena to go 18-13 in doubles, including 13-8 from the No. 1 position and 3-6 in GLIAC action.