Tiffin University (8-4-5, 6-4-4 GMAC) came from behind to tie the game in the second half before settling for a 1-1 draw with Findlay in its regular season finale.
The game was important for Tiffin's post season seeding, and the draw means the Dragons have to await the outcome of other GMAC contests later this evening to find out their position in the quarterfinals Saturday.
Findlay got on the board in the 28th minute to take a 1-0 lead which they held at the half.
Findlay tried to respond immediately, sending a shot towards Dylan Morris that he stopped for a save. It was the last shot on goal either team had in regulation.
In the first overtime, Findlay had another chance but Morris posted another save to send it to the second overtime.
Hasenstab had another shot to give TU the win in the second overtime but Findlay made the save to preserve the draw.
Overall Morris made 10 saves in the game over 110 minutes.
Findlay outshot TU 17-16 including 11-6 on goal, while also leading 6-3 in corner kicks.